1 Intensive Care Unit, Royal Adelaide Hospital, Central Adelaide Local Health Network, SA Health, Adelaide, Australia
2 Australian Institute of Health Innovation, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia
3 IIMPACT in Health, Allied Health and Human Performance, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia
4 DonateLife South Australia, Adelaide, Australia
5 Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia
Correspondence to: Fraser Moss — Fraser.Moss@sa.gov.au
Cite as: Moss F, Hibbert P, Van Gasteren C, Kocher MK, Moodie S, Sundararajan K. A mixed-methods evaluation of a quality improvement initiative for flexible ICU visits in an Australian quaternary centre. South Aust J Med. 2026;1(2):e0015.
DOI: 10.66861/NVGJ9656 Open access · CC BY 4.0
Submitted 3 Jul 2026 Accepted 24 Aug 2026 Published 1 Sep 2026
Abstract
Background: Restrictive ICU visitation is a recognised source of caregiver distress, particularly at the end-of-life. In response to recurring caregiver feedback, we implemented a criteria-based flexible visitation model in a large Australian ICU. We evaluated the implementation, its impact on caregiver experience and its acceptability among ICU staff.
Methods: We conducted a mixed-methods evaluation of a two-phase quality improvement initiative that comprised the Blue Dot pathway (flexible visitation for patients at the end-of-life) and the Orange Dot pathway (criteria-based flexible visitation for selected patients with compassionate needs). De-identified caregiver feedback from a bereavement follow-up service was retrospectively analysed. Comments about visitation were coded as positive or negative, and compared before and after each phase. Staff acceptability was assessed via an anonymous survey.
Results: For the Blue Dot pathway, 271 surveys were analysed (129 before, 142 after). Negative comments decreased from 14.4% to 3.3% (−11.1%; 95% CI −17.3 to −4.7; p = 0.006), and positive comments increased modestly but were not significant. For the Orange Dot pathway, 180 surveys were analysed (95 before, 85 after); there was no significant change in positive sentiment (+5.3%; p = 0.18) or negative sentiment (+2.6%; p = 0.33). A total of 136 staff responded (25% response rate), and 72% supported continuation.
Conclusion: Flexible ICU visitation was associated with reduced negative caregiver feedback during end-of-life care and high staff acceptability. It was extended to broader patient groups and demonstrated high levels of staff acceptability, although no significant change in caregiver sentiment was observed.
Keywords: flexible visitation · Intensive Care Unit · end-of-life · compassionate care · caregiver experience
Editor’s preface
Flexible visitation at the end of life measurably eased caregiver distress. Extending that same flexibility more broadly didn’t move the needle either way — a useful reminder that “family-centred” reform doesn’t land the same everywhere it’s tried.
— The Editors
Background
Flexible visitation has been associated with improved patient and caregiver outcomes in intensive care.1 However, implementation is often limited by staff concerns about workload and workflow disruption.2
The ICU at the Royal Adelaide Hospital (RAH) is a 48-bed quaternary unit that serves a geographically and culturally diverse population, including rural and Indigenous patients. Routine bereavement follow-up conducted before the COVID-19 pandemic identified restricted visitation—particularly at the end-of-life—as a recurring source of caregiver distress.3 Informal exemptions to visitation rules were inconsistently applied, contributing to inequity in caregiver access. Australian studies have demonstrated variability in the delivery of end-of-life care (EOLC) and emphasised the importance of communication and family involvement in shaping caregiver experience.4 Post-intensive care syndrome and its counterpart in caregivers, post-intensive care syndrome–family, describe the physical, cognitive and psychological sequelae that may persist after critical illness.5 Restricted visitation may contribute to both conditions. Evidence supports flexible ICU visitation as a strategy to reduce delirium, anxiety and psychological morbidity without increasing infection risk1,6–8; observational studies have demonstrated improved caregiver satisfaction.9–11 A before-and-after study also reported reduced delirium without increased infection risk.12 However, staff concerns about workload, workflow disruption and burnout remained key barriers.2,13
In 2018, a joint task force, comprising representatives from the ICU at The Royal Adelaide Hospital and DonateLife South Australia, was established to improve EOLC within the ICU. Through this collaboration, limited bedside access during EOLC was identified as a modifiable contributor to caregiver distress, leading to the development of the Blue Dot pathway. The Blue Dot pathway initially focused on improving bedside access for patients receiving EOLC.
The COVID-19 pandemic further highlighted this issue;14 at the RAH visits were highly restricted during the peak of the pandemic,15 and there was ongoing variability in the visitation policy after the severity of the pandemic eased. Building on the Blue Dot pathway, and the experience during the COVID-19 pandemic, the Orange Dot pathway was developed to extend flexible visitation to selected patients who had compassionate or clinical needs. The evolution of these quality improvement initiatives is summarised in Figure 1.

Aim
We hypothesised that implementing a criteria-based flexible ICU visitation would reduce negative caregiver experience, compared with standard visitation, particularly during EOLC.
The objective of this study was to evaluate a staged quality improvement program that comprised the Blue Dot pathway and its subsequent extension, the Orange Dot pathway. Specifically, we evaluated caregiver-reported experiences after the Blue Dot pathway was implemented, and staff acceptance of the Orange Dot pathway, while exploring changes in caregiver-reported experiences during the broader implementation period.
Methods
We used a mixed-methods observational evaluation of a staged quality improvement program that comprised two sequential phases. A mixed-methods approach was adopted retrospectively to provide complementary perspectives on the program by combining routinely collected caregiver feedback with staff acceptability feedback after the Orange Dot pathway was implemented. Quantitative and qualitative findings were interpreted together to provide a broader understanding of caregiver experiences, staff perceptions and program implementation than either data source could provide alone.
Intervention design and phases
The Blue Dot pathway was implemented through an existing ICU–DonateLife EOLC collaboration, which was established in 2018 to support ongoing quality improvement in EOLC. This collaboration involved the embedded EOLC nursing service working with senior ICU medical and nursing stakeholders. The Blue Dot pathway was introduced in August 2019 and provided flexible visitation for patients identified as being at the end of life, allowing unrestricted caregiver presence at the bedside.
During periods of mandated COVID-19 visitation restrictions, implementation of the Blue Dot pathway was superseded by jurisdictional public health directives. Following the easing of these restrictions, the Blue Dot pathway was reinstated as the standard approach to end-of-life visitation. Building on the lessons from the Blue Dot pathway, pandemic-related challenges and ongoing caregiver feedback, the study team introduced the Orange Dot pathway (Pathway 2) in April 2024 to extend flexible visitation to selected patients who had compassionate or clinical needs. Eligible situations included complex caregiver dynamics, communication barriers, behavioural needs (e.g. delirium) and cases in which caregiver presence was considered clinically beneficial (see Table 1).
| Category | Criteria |
|---|---|
| Timing of admission | Newly admitted ICU patients that require caregiver presence after hours |
| Paediatric considerations | Paediatric patients that require the presence of an adult caregiver |
| Visitor accessibility | Visitors arriving from overseas, or rural/interstate areas, or who work outside regular hours |
| Clinical complexity | Patients that require further clarification of the treatment plan, are unstable or are reaching maximum support |
| Caregiver emotional needs | Caregivers who are experiencing emotional distress and need additional time or support services (e.g. social work, counselling) |
| Patient behavioural needs | Patients that exhibit complex behaviours (e.g. delirium) who benefit from caregiver presence |
| Communication barriers | Patients who have language barriers and require caregiver support or informal translation |
Importantly, the Orange Dot pathway supplemented, rather than replaced, the existing Blue Dot pathway, which remained in place for patients receiving EOLC throughout the study period. Consequently, the two pathways were not mutually exclusive, and the Orange Dot pathway was an extension of the existing flexible visitation program rather than a separate controlled intervention. Figure 2 illustrates the development of the Blue and Orange Dot pathways for flexible visitation.

Implementation of the Orange Dot pathway was led by the EOLC nursing service in the ICU, in discussion with the ICU consultant group. Before it was implemented, information about the purpose, eligibility criteria, governance processes and documentation requirements was disseminated to all ICU staff through departmental email communications and clinical huddles. Following its implementation, the pathway was refined iteratively in response to informal staff feedback; its core principles and governance were maintained.
Unlike the Blue Dot pathway, which permitted unrestricted visits at the end-of-life, the Orange Dot pathway enabled increased but moderated visits, typically allowing extended access for a limited number of caregivers at any one time.
The two pathways were implemented as part of routine clinical practice. Patient selection and ongoing review were undertaken by the multidisciplinary ICU team. For patients not selected for either pathway, visitation decisions were made at clinician discretion on a case-by-case basis. These discretionary decisions were not systematically documented and are not included in this dataset.
The number of patients receiving Blue Dot or Orange Dot visitation access was not prospectively recorded, because the pathways were implemented as part of routine clinical practice. Therefore, exposure to the intervention at an individual patient level could not be quantified. Consequently, analyses were conducted at a cohort level to compare caregiver-reported experiences across periods before and after the implementation of each pathway.
Outcome measures
We used a mixed-methods framework to evaluate the impact of the Blue Dot and Orange Dot flexible visitation interventions. To assess caregiver satisfaction, we compared pre-intervention and post-intervention data for the two pathways. In addition, we evaluated the staff’s acceptance of the Orange Dot pathway as well as staff experience with it by using an anonymous staff survey. Caregiver outcomes were the proportions of completed interviews containing negative or positive visitation-related comments before and after the implementation of each pathway.
For the Blue Dot pathway, interviews conducted before August 2019 were with the pre-intervention cohort; interviews conducted from August 2019 onwards were with the post-intervention cohort. Similarly, for the Orange Dot pathway, interviews conducted before April 2024 were with the pre-intervention cohort, and those conducted from April 2024 onwards were with the post-intervention cohort.
Caregiver satisfaction
The EOLC service collected qualitative data on caregivers’ satisfaction on an ongoing basis, before, during and after the implementation of each visitation pathway.
Blue Dot pathway
During the Blue Dot study period, bereaved caregivers of 481 patients who died in the ICU were invited to participate in bereavement follow-up (February 2018 to 18 May 2020). This resulted in 917 follow-up call attempts. Multiple contact attempts were made for some patients, in line with routine practice. Contact with a caregiver was successfully established in 337 cases, of which 271 completed interviews that formed the dataset for analysis. In the remaining cases, either no contact was made, participation was declined or incomplete data were recorded.
Orange Dot pathway
During the Orange Dot study period (May 2023 to May 2025), bereaved caregivers of 706 patients who died in the ICU were invited to participate in bereavement follow-up. This resulted in 1,516 follow-up call attempts. Multiple contact attempts were made for some patients, in line with routine practice. Contact with a caregiver was successfully established in 581 cases, of which 180 completed interviews that formed the dataset for analysis. In the remaining cases, no contact was made, participation was declined or incomplete data were recorded. As with the Blue Dot pathway, cases in which no contact was made, participation was declined or incomplete data were recorded were excluded.
Bereavement follow-up was conducted by telephone by the EOLC nursing service at the ICU, typically six to 12 weeks after the patient’s death. All members of the EOLC nursing team were trained to administer the modified CAESAR-based survey16 and to enter these data in the REDCap (Research Electronic Data Capture) database. The survey was administered as a voluntary, 30-minute semi-structured interview. Complete and incomplete survey records were retained in REDCap; however, only completed surveys were included in the present analysis. Details of the modified survey are provided in Appendix A.
Caregiver satisfaction was assessed using a routine bereavement follow-up survey. The modified CAESAR-based survey explored caregivers’ experiences across several domains of EOLC, including communication, emotional support, decision-making and overall satisfaction with care.
We searched the completed surveys for comments relating to visitation or access to patients before and after each implementation period, building on prior thematic work that has identified visitation as a key issue in EOLC.17 Relevant comments were extracted from the de-identified records by the primary author (FM). Because the free-text comments had been documented verbatim, sentiment classification was in accordance with the caregiver’s recorded words rather than an interviewer-generated summary.
The completed interview was the unit of analysis. Each interview was classified as containing either a positive visitation-related comment, a negative visitation-related comment or no positive or negative visitation-related comment. Classifications were mutually exclusive, and each interview contributed no more than one observation. Interviews without visitation-related comments, and those containing only neutral comments, remained in the denominator but did not contribute to either numerator. The proportions of completed interviews that contained positive and negative visitation-related comments were calculated separately for each period and compared using two-proportion Z tests with 95% confidence intervals; p values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Inter-rater analysis of caregiver interview data (Blue Dot and Orange Dot pathways)
All interview comments referring to visitation or access to patients who were receiving EOLC were double-coded. This included comments from before and after the introduction of both the Blue Dot and Orange Dot pathways. The primary author classified each comment as either containing visitation-related content or not. A second analyst, blinded to these classifications, then independently (i) noted whether visitation content was present and (ii) labelled any such comment as either ‘positive’ or ‘negative’. Agreement between the two coders was quantified across the full dataset using Cohen’s κ for both the presence–absence decision and the positive–negative sentiment assignment. Suggestion-type remarks were excluded from this reliability exercise.
Staff acceptance and experience
The staff acceptance and experience survey was conducted between 10 January and 31 January 2025, approximately nine months after the implementation of the Orange Dot pathway. Data were collected using an electronic survey platform (SurveyMonkey), and stored centrally and securely. Given that no validated instrument specific to this intervention was identified, a purpose-designed questionnaire was developed by the study team to evaluate staff awareness, acceptance and perceived impact of the Orange Dot pathway. The questionnaire underwent informal review by members of the study team to ensure clarity and relevance before distribution. The survey included multiple-choice, Likert-scale and free-text questions (see Appendix B).
Open-ended responses from the staff survey were analysed by the primary author (FM) using inductive thematic analysis following the six-phase approach described by Braun and Clarke.18 Responses to the four open-ended questions (Q7, Q8, Q11 and Q12) were coded to identify recurring ideas, which were then iteratively grouped into broader thematic categories according to conceptual similarity. The themes were reviewed and refined through repeated analysis to ensure clarity and consistency. Each response was subsequently assigned an overall positive or negative sentiment in accordance with its expressed meaning within the relevant thematic category. Theme frequencies were calculated and expressed as a percentage of all comments.
To assess the reliability of the developed coding framework across the breadth of the identified themes, a purposive subsample of 36 staff comments was selected. This included all responses containing less common themes, together with a random sample of the remaining responses. A second blinded analyst independently applied the predefined coding framework. Inter-rater agreement was quantified using Cohen’s κ for identification of positive and negative comments and for assignment of the corresponding thematic subcategories.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This quality improvement project used de-identified data collected as part of routine care. The Central Adelaide Local Health Network Human Research Ethics Committee confirmed that formal ethics approval was not required (Reference 22244). Participation in both the bereavement follow-up interviews and staff survey was voluntary. Consent was implied by participation.
Results
Blue Dot
In 129 pre-intervention and 142 post-intervention surveys, negative caregiver comments decreased from 14.4% to 3.3% (absolute reduction 11.1 percentage points, 95% CI −17.3 to −4.7; p = 0.006). Positive comments increased from 8.8% to 13.3% (absolute increase 4.5 percentage points, 95% CI −3.7 to 12.6; p = 0.25), although this difference was not statistically significant.
Orange Dot
In 95 pre-intervention and 85 post-intervention surveys, there was no statistically significant change in caregiver sentiment. Positive comments increased from 5.3% to 10.6% (absolute increase 5.3 percentage points, 95% CI −2.6 to 13.3; p = 0.18), and negative comments increased from 2.1% to 4.7% (absolute increase 2.6 percentage points, 95% CI −2.7 to 7.9; p = 0.33).
Inter-rater reliability ranged from moderate to almost perfect across both caregiver datasets. For the Blue Dot interviews (n = 113 comments), coders showed moderate agreement in detecting visitation content (κ = 0.52) and almost perfect agreement in classifying sentiment as positive or negative (κ = 0.90). For the Orange Dot interviews (n = 40), agreement was substantial for content detection (κ = 0.70) and perfect for sentiment classification (κ = 1.00). Table 2 and Figure 3 summarise the changes in visitation-related caregiver sentiment.
| Intervention | Δ Positive* | 95% CI | p value | Δ Negative* | 95% CI | p value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blue Dot | +4.5% | −3.7 to 12.6 | 0.25 | −11.1% | −17.3 to −4.7 | 0.006 |
| Orange Dot | +5.3% | −2.6 to 13.3 | 0.18 | +2.6% | −2.7 to 7.9 | 0.33 |

Staff survey analysis
A total of 136 staff responded (25% response rate), including nurses (61%), doctors (25%) and allied health staff (14%). Most respondents supported continuation of the Orange Dot pathway (72%). In a separate question that addressed flexible visitation policies more broadly, 98 respondents (74%) believed that flexible visitation should continue in the ICU. Perceived benefits included improved communication, caregiver reassurance and reduced patient agitation.
Overall, 59% of respondents were satisfied or very satisfied, and 15% were dissatisfied. Satisfaction was highest among doctors (78.6%), compared with 53.4% among nurses and 66.7% among allied health staff.
A total of 182 free-text comments were analysed thematically. Figures 4 and 5 illustrate the major positive and negative themes identified from the staff comments. Representative staff quotations are presented in Table 3.


| Theme | Positive staff comments | Negative staff comments |
|---|---|---|
| Patient anxiety and delirium | ‘Patients relax more with family present.’ ‘Mother stayed overnight, reducing daughter’s anxiety and staff workload.’ ‘Helps manage delirium by engaging patients.’ | ‘Spouse worsened anxiety by coaching patient off the ventilator.’ ‘Family presence sometimes increases patient stress.’ ‘Intoxicated visitor caused significant disruption.’ |
| Provision of patient care | ‘Delirious patients are easier to manage with familiar faces.’ ‘Early family presence improves communication and care.’ ‘Relatives assist in care tasks.’ | ‘Families sometimes obstruct interventions.’ ‘Constant interaction disrupted patient rest.’ ‘Overcrowding during procedures increased stress for staff.’ |
| Communication | ‘Family helped translate for the non-English speaking patient.’ ‘Expedited updates and goals-of-care discussions.’ ‘Relatives helpful with confused patients.’ | ‘Hard to have confidential discussions with family always present.’ ‘Conflicting messages from multiple teams led to confusion.’ |
| Caregiver and staff morale | ‘Relatives share patient preferences, improving care.’ ‘Flexible visitation allowed family presence during final moments.’ | ‘Large families made staff feel anxious.’ ‘Families frustrated when re-entry wasn’t possible due to volunteer absence.’ |
Agreement was substantial for detection of negative content (κ = 0.80), moderate for detection of positive content (κ = 0.47), fair for negative subtheme assignment (κ = 0.23) and moderate for positive subtheme assignment (κ = 0.41). Figure 4 illustrates the distribution of positive themes, and Figure 5 presents the negative. The cumulative percentage line in Figure 5 demonstrates the proportion of all negative comments accounted for by the most-frequently reported themes.
Supporting patients who suffered from delirium and anxiety was the most-frequently cited benefit of Orange Dot visitation in the staff survey responses. Supporting families, addressing language and cultural needs, assisting with palliative care, and supporting various aspects of general patient care accounted for the remaining positive themes in the comments.
Hindering bedside ICU care and staff stress were the most-frequently cited concerns in the staff survey responses, together accounting for almost two-thirds of the negative comments. Concerns about overcrowding, patient privacy and potential increases in patient stress accounted for a minority of the remaining themes in the comments.
Staff suggested clearer eligibility criteria, more consistent application of the visitation pathway, improved communication between the multidisciplinary team, regular multidisciplinary review of visitation decisions, and greater support for managing increased workload and visitor expectations. When staff were asked whether they believed that flexible visitation policies should be continued in the ICU, 98 (74%) agreed, 13 (10%) disagreed and 22 (16.5%) were unsure.
Discussion
Principal findings
This quality improvement evaluation described the implementation of a criteria-based, flexible visitation model in a large quaternary ICU and explored its association with caregiver-reported experiences and staff acceptance. The Blue Dot pathway, when applied to patients at the end-of-life, was associated with a marked reduction in negative caregiver comments about visitation. In contrast, extension of flexible visitation to a broader patient cohort through the Orange Dot pathway was not associated with statistically significant changes in caregiver sentiment but demonstrated high levels of staff acceptance and perceived clinical utility.
These findings should be interpreted as observational signals within a pragmatic service improvement initiative rather than evidence of causation.
Interpretation in context of existing literature
Our findings are consistent with observational studies that have similarly reported improved caregiver satisfaction under more permissive visitation policies.9–11
Meta-analyses and randomised trials have demonstrated benefits including reduced delirium, anxiety and post-traumatic stress symptoms without increased infection risk.1,6–8
In our study, reductions in negative caregiver feedback during the Blue Dot pathway align with these findings, particularly in EOLC when access to a patient is a key determinant of perceived quality of care. However, given that the caregiver interviews were not specifically designed to evaluate visitations, and that sentiment was derived from retrospective coding of qualitative comments, these findings should be interpreted cautiously.
Caregiver interviews during the Orange Dot implementation period did not demonstrate measurable changes in visitation-related sentiment. However, these interviews were restricted to bereaved caregivers, whereas the Orange Dot pathway primarily targeted patients outside of EOLC. For this reason, these findings should be interpreted as contextual observations rather than as a direct evaluation of the intervention’s effectiveness for its intended target population. Several factors may explain why caregiver-reported visitation sentiment did not measurably improve after the Orange Dot pathway was implemented. Unlike the Blue Dot pathway, which addressed a clearly defined source of caregiver distress at the end-of-life, the Orange Dot pathway extended flexible visitation to a more heterogeneous patient population. In addition, the relatively small number of caregiver comments and the inability to quantify implementation fidelity may have reduced the ability to detect measurable changes. However, high levels of staff support and qualitative feedback that described perceived improvements in communication, delirium management and caregiver engagement suggest that the intervention was feasible and valued in clinical practice.
Strengths
This study has several strengths. First, it represents a pragmatic real-world evaluation developed in response to consumer feedback. Second, the mixed-methods approach allowed triangulation of caregiver-reported experience and staff perspectives, providing a more comprehensive understanding of the intervention. Third, inter-rater reliability results indicate that the two coders applied the sentiment classification consistently.
Limitations
Several limitations should be acknowledged. This was a single-centre, quality improvement evaluation without a control group, which limited the ability to draw causal inferences. The overlap in the implementation of the Blue Dot and Orange Dot pathways further limits the ability to isolate the independent effects of each intervention.
Caregiver data were derived from voluntary bereavement follow-up interviews, which introduced potential selection bias, namely, an over-representation of caregivers who were contactable and willing to participate. In addition, interviews were conducted after the patient’s death, which may have introduced recall bias. Not all interviews contained comments relating to visitation, and analysis was restricted to comments explicitly referencing access to a patient, which may not have fully captured the overall caregiver experience.
Interview completion among caregivers contacted was lower during the Orange Dot evaluation than during the Blue Dot evaluation. The reasons for this difference cannot be surmised. Consequently, additional selection bias cannot be ruled out, and comparability between the two evaluation periods should be considered with caution. The number of deaths and bereavement follow-up records differed between the Blue Dot and Orange Dot evaluation periods. The reasons for this variation may reflect changes in ICU activity, EOLC service processes, referral practices or data capture over time. The cohorts were derived from available bereavement follow-up records rather than matched patient populations.
The use of a modified CAESAR-based approach and binary sentiment classification was not formally validated for this specific analytical purpose. Further, the relatively small number of visitation-related comments in the analysis of the Orange Dot pathway may have limited the ability to detect meaningful differences.
Although the Blue Dot pathway became embedded in routine EOLC and the Orange Dot pathway was implemented across the unit, the evaluation did not include a prospective measure of implementation fidelity, such as the frequency or consistency with which either pathway was activated.
Finally, no patient-level clinical outcomes (such as delirium, length of stay or post-intensive care syndrome) were measured, and therefore the clinical impact of the intervention remains uncertain. Given that individual patient exposure to Blue Dot or Orange Dot visitation could not be quantified, observed changes in caregiver experiences cannot be directly attributed to the intervention. Our findings therefore reflect system-level effects associated with the implementation rather than patient-level effects of the intervention.
Implications for practice and policy
Despite these limitations, this study demonstrates that a criteria-based flexible visitation model can be implemented within a large quaternary ICU and may be transferable to other adult ICUs that seek to balance compassionate, family-centred care with operational demands. A structured criteria-based approach may provide a pragmatic framework that can be adapted to local contexts. The Blue Dot pathway may provide a structured approach to ensuring compassionate access during EOLC, and the Orange Dot pathway potentially offers a way to extend this flexibility to other patient groups with defined needs.
Importantly, staff feedback highlights the need for clear guidelines, consistent application and ongoing multidisciplinary review to balance the benefits of caregiver presence with potential impacts on workflow and privacy. Similar concerns regarding the impact of flexible visitation on staff workload and professional activity have been reported in previous studies.19,20
Future research
Future work should include a prospective evaluation of the Orange Dot pathway that incorporates measures of intervention uptake, caregiver experiences and clinical outcomes, such as delirium and length of stay.
Multi-centre prospective studies with validated outcomes would improve generalisability. Additional qualitative work that explores the experiences of culturally diverse and Indigenous populations may help refine visitation models to better meet the needs of these groups.
Conclusion
In this single-centre quality improvement evaluation, implementation of criteria-based flexible ICU visitation was associated with reduced negative caregiver feedback during EOLC and high levels of staff acceptance. Extension of the model to a broader patient population was feasible but not associated with statistically significant changes in caregiver sentiment. Nonetheless, a structured, criteria-based approach to flexible visitation may represent a pragmatic and sustainable strategy to improve caregiver experiences in ICU settings.
Appendices
The two survey instruments referred to in the Methods are available as downloadable PDFs.
References
- Wu Y, Wang G, Zhang Z, Fan L, Ma F, Yue W, et al. Efficacy and safety of unrestricted visiting policy for critically ill patients: a meta-analysis. Crit Care. 2022;26(1):267. doi:10.1186/s13054-022-04129-3.
- Eugênio CS, Haack TDSR, Teixeira C, Rosa RG, de Souza EN. Comparison between the perceptions of family members and health professionals regarding a flexible visitation model in an adult intensive care unit: a cross-sectional study. Rev Bras Ter Intensiva. 2022;34(3):374–9. doi:10.5935/0103-507X.20220114-en.
- Yeo NYK, Reddi B, Kocher M, Wilson S, Jastrzebski N, Duncan K, et al. Collaboration between the intensive care unit and organ donation agency to achieve routine consideration of organ donation and comprehensive bereavement follow-up: an improvement project in a quaternary Australian hospital. Aust Health Rev. 2021;45(1):124–31. doi:10.1071/AH20005.
- Mitchell I, Lacey J, Anstey M, Corbett C, Douglas C, Drummond C, et al. Understanding end-of-life care in Australian hospitals. Aust Health Rev. 2021;45(5):540–7. doi:10.1071/AH20223.
- Schembari G, Santonocito C, Messina S, Caruso A, Cardia L, Rubulotta F, et al. Post-intensive care syndrome as a burden for patients and their caregivers: a narrative review. J Clin Med. 2024;13(19):5881. doi:10.3390/jcm13195881.
- Rosa RG, Falavigna M, da Silva DB, Sganzerla D, Santos MMS, Kochhann R, et al. Effect of flexible family visitation on delirium among patients in the intensive care unit: the ICU Visits randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2019;322(3):216–28. doi:10.1001/jama.2019.8766.
- Yang HY, Feng F, Yang WW, Chen Y. Application of a flexible visitation system in critically ill patients: a randomized clinical trial. Sci Prog. 2023;106(1):368504231165663. doi:10.1177/00368504231165663.
- de Souza JMB, Miozzo AP, da Rosa Minho Dos Santos R, Mocellin D, Rech GS, Trott G, et al. Long-term effects of flexible visitation in the intensive care unit on family members’ mental health: 12-month results from a randomized clinical trial. Intensive Care Med. 2024;50(10):1614–21. doi:10.1007/s00134-024-07577-3.
- Mitchell ML, Aitken LM. Flexible visiting positively impacted on patients, families and staff in an Australian intensive care unit: a before-after mixed method study. Aust Crit Care. 2017;30(2):91–7. doi:10.1016/j.aucc.2016.01.001.
- Fumis RRL, Ranzani OT, Faria PP, Schettino G. Anxiety, depression, and satisfaction in close relatives of patients in an open visiting policy intensive care unit in Brazil. J Crit Care. 2015;30(2):440.e1–6. doi:10.1016/j.jcrc.2014.11.022.
- Fergé JL, Banydeen R, Le Terrier C, Fize H, Miguel M, Kentish-Barnes N, et al. Mental health of adolescent relatives of intensive care patients: benefits of an open visitation policy. Am J Crit Care. 2021;30(1):72–6. doi:10.4037/ajcc2021799.
- Rosa RG, Tonietto TF, da Silva DB, Gutierres FA, Ascoli AM, Madeira LC, et al. Effectiveness and safety of an extended ICU visitation model for delirium prevention: a before and after study. Crit Care Med. 2017;45(10):1660–7. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000002588.
- Nassar Junior AP, Besen BAMP, Robinson CC, Falavigna M, Teixeira C, Rosa RG. Flexible versus restrictive visiting policies in ICUs: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Crit Care Med. 2018;46(7):1175–80. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000003155.
- Rose L, Cook A, Onwumere J, Terblanche E, Pattison N, Metaxa V, et al. Psychological distress and morbidity of family members experiencing virtual visiting in intensive care during COVID-19: an observational cohort study. Intensive Care Med. 2022;48(9):1156–64. doi:10.1007/s00134-022-06824-9.
- Nadkarni A, Alderson S, Collett L, Maiden M, Reddi B, Sundararajan K. Impact of COVID-19 on an Australian intensive care unit: lessons learned from South Australia. Intern Med J. 2020;50(9):1146–50. doi:10.1111/imj.14963.
- Kentish-Barnes N, Seegers V, Legriel S, Cariou A, Jaber S, Lefrant JY, et al. CAESAR: a new tool to assess relatives’ experience of dying and death in the ICU. Intensive Care Med. 2016;42(6):995–1002. doi:10.1007/s00134-016-4260-4.
- Carter D, Moodie S, Reddi B, Yeo N, Laver H, Sundararajan K. How bereaved families conceptualise good care and communication in intensive care in South Australia. BMC Health Serv Res. 2024;24(1):1617. doi:10.1186/s12913-024-11877-1.
- Braun V, Clarke V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol. 2006;3(2):77–101. doi:10.1191/1478088706qp063oa.
- Ayllón Garrido N, Montero Rus P, Acebes Fernández MI, Sánchez Zugazua J. Unidad de cuidados intensivos de puertas abiertas: perspectiva de los profesionales. Enferm Intensiva. 2014;25(2):72–7. doi:10.1016/j.enfi.2013.11.007.
- Alonso-Rodríguez A, Martínez-Villamea S, Sánchez-Vallejo A, Gallego-Lorenzo J, Fernández-Menéndez M. Perspectives of intensive care nurses on open visits in an ICU. Enferm Intensiva (Engl Ed). 2021;32(2):62–72. doi:10.1016/j.enfie.2020.02.007.
Acknowledgements: We thank the ICU nursing, medical and allied health staff for facilitating data collection, and we are especially grateful to the caregivers who generously shared their experiences. The authors wish to acknowledge the work of reviewers including Dr Andrew Booth, Dr Nic Anning and other anonymous reviewers.
| Role | Author(s) |
|---|---|
| Conceptualisation | Fraser Moss (FM), Peter Hibbert (PH), Krishnaswamy Sundararajan (KS) |
| Data curation | Chantal Van Gasteren (CVG), Mandy Kaye Kocher (MKK), Stewart Moodie (SM) |
| Methodology | FM, PH, CVG, MKK, KS |
| Formal analysis | FM, PH |
| Investigation | FM, CVG, MKK |
| Visualisation | FM |
| Writing: original draft | FM |
| Writing: review and editing | PH, CVG, MKK, SM, KS |
| Supervision | KS |
| Project administration | FM |
| Resources | KS |
All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Funding statement: This study received no external funding. All data collection and analysis activities were supported by internal resources from the Intensive Care Unit of the Royal Adelaide Hospital.
Conflict of interest statement: The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Ethics approval: This quality improvement project analysed de-identified data collected as part of routine clinical care, together with responses from a voluntary anonymous staff survey. The Central Adelaide Local Health Network Human Research Ethics Committee confirmed that formal ethics approval was not required (Reference 22244). Participation in both the routine bereavement follow-up service and the staff survey was voluntary, with consent implied by participation.
Consent for publication: Not applicable.
Data availability statement: De-identified study data are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Use of AI tools: A generative AI tool was used only for language editing (grammar, syntax and clarity) on author-written text. The authors reviewed and approved all changes and take full responsibility for the content.