The South Australian Journal of Medicine (SAJM) is a peer‑reviewed journal committed to rigorous, fair, and timely assessment of all published work. The SAJM peer review process accords with international best practice, based on guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).
Peer review model
SAJM uses a double‑anonymised peer review model for most scholarly content. Authors do not know the identity of reviewers, and reviewers do not know the identity of authors. Two independent reviewers are standard for original research, reviews, case series, and substantial case-based or clinical practice papers; the Editor-in-Chief may seek additional review where warranted.
Editorials, invited commentaries, clinicopathologic conferences, and some commissioned materials may be assessed by the Editor‑in‑Chief and/or Editorial Board members with internal review, but are still evaluated for accuracy, clarity, and relevance, and may be referred to external peer review should this be deemed necessary by editorial staff.
What is reviewed
External peer review is normally required for:
- Original research (quantitative, qualitative, mixed‑methods)
- Clinical audits and service evaluations
- Narrative or systematic reviews
- Case series and substantial case‑based discussions
- Clinical practice guidelines, protocols, and quality‑improvement reports
Short letters, corrections, and some invited content may undergo streamlined review, at the Editor’s discretion.
Reviewer selection and responsibilities
Reviewers are selected for their subject‑matter and/or methodological expertise and must not have disqualifying conflicts of interest. SAJM may consider, but is not bound by, author suggestions for suitable reviewers and/or requests to exclude specific reviewers where this is justifiable.
Reviewers are expected to:
- Maintain strict confidentiality of all manuscripts and not share or use ideas for their own benefit or benefit to people other than the authors.
- Declare potential conflicts of interest and decline reviews where appropriate.
- Provide constructive, respectful, and evidence‑informed comments to help editors reach a decision and help authors improve their work. Reviewers are encouraged to use the reviewer template provided.
- Submit reviews within the agreed timeframe or promptly notify the editor if an extension or withdrawal is needed.
SAJM’s detailed guidance for peer reviewers is available on our “Guidance for Reviewers” page, which aligns with COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
Editorial decisions
Editors consider reviewer reports, their own assessment, and the journal’s aims and scope when making decisions. Possible outcomes include acceptance; requests for minor or major revision; revision with mentoring; or reject. Authors receive anonymised reviewer comments and a decision letter explaining the next steps.”
Revision with mentoring is a formal editorial outcome in which an author works iteratively with an assigned editor or senior colleague toward a publishable manuscript. It is offered where a submission shows genuine clinical or scholarly merit but requires more structured support than a standard revision process provides.
SAJM also offers a reviewer mentoring pathway for those who wish to develop their skills in critical appraisal. Reviewers at any stage of their career may request pairing with a more experienced reviewer or editor, who will work alongside them through the review process and provide formative feedback on their reports. If this interests you, even before being asked to review, please email eic@sajm.au to register your interest.
Revisions of manuscripts MUST be accompanied by a response document addressing each reviewer comment point‑by‑point, indicating changes made or providing a clear rationale where changes are not made. This approach makes the process more structured for the authors and assists the editorial staff. SAJM offers a downloadable template for reviewers to use.
Confidentiality, ethics, and appeals
All participants in the editorial and peer review process are required to keep submissions and reviews in strict confidence, and must never use unpublished material for personal advantage or to benefit others in a way that is unfair or not transparently disclosed. SAJM follows COPE and ICMJE guidance for handling suspected ethical issues (such as plagiarism, data fabrication, or undisclosed conflicts) and may seek clarification, corrections, or retractions when needed.
Authors who believe there has been a serious error of fact or process in the peer review of their manuscript may appeal the decision rendered. Appeals are considered in light of the journal’s policies and may involve additional independent editorial or reviewer input; decisions delivered after appeal are final.